Philosophers World Cup: Group D Preview

Welcome to the Group D preview for the upcoming Philosophers World Cup. Below, you can find rosters and predictions for all teams in Group D, which includes Uruguay, Costa Rica, England, and Italy. Refer to the introduction to understand what this is all about.

 

 

Uruguay was considered one of the strongest sides in South America, but limped into fifth place in the COMNEBOL qualifying group. These forced the team into a playoff against Jordan to reach the World Cup, which Uruguay won handily. Meanwhile, Costa Rica punched above its weight class to finish in second place in CONCACAF, a campaign that included upset wins over Mexico and the United States. England won its UEFA group to qualify outright, but did so in underwhelming fashion, besting a game Ukraine side by a single point in the final standings. Italy also won its UEFA group, scoring the same number of points of England, but finishing six clear of second-place Denmark.

England and Italy enter Group D as the favorites to advance. England has drawn criticism from some quarters for its selection of Terry Eagleton to play right back, who is thought to be too retrograde to contribute at that position. However, team captain Bede countered by pointing out that England’s philosophers have tended to favor a fairly conservative style, and noted that a similar criticism could be levied at the majority of the squad which lacks the post-structuralist flair of some of the continental teams. The winner of the group will likely be decided by which corpus is in play during the England / Italy match. The Italian side is being typified as having a quite confidence of its chances to win the group. Midfield Marcus Aurelius exuded this quality when he told the media, “All we must do is play a clean match, nothing else is particularly important.” Pundits question whether the Italians can play cohesively, since they are drawn from an array of eras and viewpoints. However, the Italian media points to the presence of Umberto Eco, who provides an example of how to synthesize various approaches to football.

Uruguay has the potential to cause an upset as they match up against England fairly well in the Spanish corpus. Ángel Rama leads a fearsome team of forwards taken from the Generación del 45. Although Uruguay’s forwards are unified, there is discord in the midfield with José Enrique Rodó and Carlos Vaz Ferreira disagreeing about the validity of adopting the utilitarian tactics of the English. If Uruguay can fix these issues and get some matches in the Spanish corpus, it can potentially pull some upsets and advance out of the group. Costa Rica will be hoping to face England in the Spanish corpus as well, but are unlikely to win any of matches. Draws are a possibility, but will require a great deal of luck.

Prediction:
Italy
England
Uruguay
Costa Rica

Rosters


Uruguay

Uruguay

Corpus: Spanish
Team:
José Gervasio Artigas (1764) [Political]
Tristán Narvaja (1819) [Theologian]
José Enrique Rodó (1871)
Carlos Vaz Ferreira (1872)
Emilio Frugoni (1880) [Political]
Arturo Ardao (1912)
Carlos Real de Azúa (1916) [Historian]
Emir Rodríguez Monegal (1921) [Aesthetics]
Ángel Rama (1926) [Aesthetics]
Alberto Methol Ferré (1929) [Historian]
Juan Luis Segundo (1935) [Theologian]


Costa Rica

Costa Rica

Corpus: Spanish
Team:
José María Castro Madriz (1818) [Political]
Aquileo J. Echeverría (1866)
Ricardo Fernández Guardia (1867) [Historian]
Eugenio Rodríguez Vega (1925) [Historian]
Carlos Meléndez Chaverri (1926) [Historian]
Claudio Gutierrez (c. 1950)


England

England

Corpus: English
Team:
Bede (672) [Theologian]
Thomas Moore (1478)
Francis Bacon (1561)
Thomas Hobbes (1588)
John Locke (1632)
Mary Wollstonecraft (1759)
John Stuart Mill (1806)
Herbert Spencer (1820)
Bertrand Russell (1872)
Eric Hobsbawm (1917) [Historian]
Terry Eagleton (1943) [Aesthetic]


 Italy

Italy

Corpus: Italian
Team:
Cicero (106 BCE)
Seneca (4 BCE)
Tacitus (CE 56) [Historian]
Marcus Aurelius (CE 121)
Boethius (CE 480)
Bonaventure (CE 1221) [Theologian]
Thomas Aquinas (CE 1225) [Theologian]
Niccolò Machiavelli (CE 1469) [Political]
Benedetto Croce (CE 1866)
Antonio Gramsci (CE 1891)
Umberto Eco (CE 1932)


Notes:

“Corpus” refers to the preferred Ngrams language corpus that is used in matchups, not the official or majority language spoken in that country.

Professions that appear in brackets refer to theorists who are not thought of as philosophers in the stricter sense. This is important per roster rule limits.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s